Seasons & Episodes
Season 1
8 episodes
E01
The Buggy Before The Horse
As Thanksgiving nears in Sugarcreek, Ohio, peace is shaken when someone is discovered secretly living in an Amish couple's winter buggy and stealing food from their cellar; while Naomi urges compassion, Cheryl senses a deeper threat tied to a wave of Main Street thefts; as clues and cryptic notes emerge, Cheryl must uncover the truth before fear overtakes the town's spirit of faith, grace, and community.
E02
A Season of Secrets
As winter settles over Sugarcreek, Cheryl Cooper is drawn into a chilling mystery when a teenage Amish girl receives cryptic texts about her cousin Mark, who vanished years earlier; what begins as a cold case unfolds into a web of secrets, hidden identities, and quiet betrayals; as Cheryl follows clues through faith, art, and family bonds, the truth reveals a powerful story of love, loss, and letting go.
E03
O Little Town of Sugarcreek
E04
Off the Beaten Path
E05
Simply Vanished
E06
Stitch in Time
E07
Mason Jar Mayhem
E08
When There's a Will
