Kristin Lehman
as Annie Flynn
Samantha Sloyan
as Bev Keane
Igby Rigney
as Warren Flynn
Rahul Kohli
as Sheriff Hassan
Annarah Cymone
as Leeza Scarborough
Annabeth Gish
as Dr. Sarah Gunning
Alex Essoe
as Mildred Gunning
Rahul Abburi
as Ali Hassan
Matt Biedel
as Sturge
Michael Trucco
as Mayor Wade Scarborough
Crystal Balint
as Dolly Scarborough
Louis Oliver
as Ooker
Henry Thomas
as Ed Flynn
Hamish Linklater
as Father Paul Hill
Kate Siegel
as Erin Greene
Zach Gilford
as Riley Flynn